Effectiveness of Remedial Treatments & Trial Results

Checking samplesTrials run in the late 1980’s using the combination of boron and fluoride were carried out in laboratory environment in conjunction with the Commonwealth and Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) confirmed adequate fungitoxic levels could be diffused into hardwood pole timbers.

The industry standard in Australia is now this combination of actives in a slow release form with the shape of a rod insert for internal decay and a bandage wrap for external decay.

Numerous inservice field trials of both methods have been completed and are still continuing.

The Australian trials include locations in Victoria, NSW and Queensland where conditions and timber species vary considerably. Extensive trials in other locations include Kenya, Sth Africa (four sites) and Uruguay.

Sampling South African Trial

South African trialsPoles sampled to determine penetration and retention levels of active ingredients over a ten year period have revealed more than adequate levels of active ingredients required to provide protection were detected in the timber.

Unlike pressure treatments, remedial treatments rely on diffusion pathways and are capable of penetrating deeply into heartwood. Trials have confirmed this to be the case.

The tests also confirmed that in decayed timber most of the chemical diffuses into the pole within the first few months killing any active decay fungus, and the treatment still remains active well after the rod or bandage has dissolved. This is an important result as it demonstrates the increased likelihood of extension of life of the pole irrespective of what may occur to the pole in the future.

Kenya Trial

Kenyan trialsExamples of some Trials to date

State Forests of New South Wales
10 year evaluation on the effectiveness of Bioguard

CSIRO (Federal Government Research Organisation)
Polesaver rod stub trial

Sydney Electricity (Now Ausgrid)
Polesaver and Bioguard field trials

The former State Electricity Commission of Victoria (SECV)
Extensive Bioguard field trial across various locations throughout Victoria

State Forests of New South Wales
Polesaver rods drilling pattern trial

South African 10 year trial

South African 10 year trial resultsOregon State University USA
Polesaver and Bioguard Stub trial

Osmose USA
Polesaver Diffusion trial in Southern Yellow Pine

Monaro Electricity (Now Essential Energy)
in conjunction with Electricity Association of NSW
Major Bioguard and Polesaver field trial at Chakola NSW

Queensland Forestry
Bioguard and Polesaver stub trial at Rocklea, Queensland

Kenya
South Africa (4 different site locations)
Uruguay

Commercial results

The rate of defective poles identified at the time of inspection is one obvious indication on the effectiveness of remedial treatment.

Remedial treatment has been utilised in Victoria since 1988 to  current date.

Powercor City Power (a large Distributor based in Victoria in the south east of Australia) has a pole population of 500,000 and commenced a pole maintenance and treatment program in 1989. The result of this initiative has been a reduction in condemnation rate from 2.9% in 1987/88 to 0.4% in 1995/96. While this is partly due to an improvement in inspection techniques, the major impact has been remedial treatment of poles affected by decay. This trend is quite typical of most other Authorities adopting pole inspection and remedial treatment programs.